Thursday Thing to Read: Wisconsin Debate Persona of the Year
December 15, 2005 – 4:10 pm by: Nick BubbFor the last two years a WDCA STOC reflection post shows up on cross-x.com. That reflection post, entitled “Wisconsin Debate Persona of the Year,” has again surfaced this year. Wisconsin Forensics Daily encourages everyone to participate in the reflection of the year that was in Wisconsin Debate. And, if you don’t want to contribute to Cross-x.com’s on going discussion, we’ll provide the list of questions right here, on Wisconsin Forensics Daily.
The Link to the Cross-x.com discussion is http://www.cross-x.com/vb/showthread.php?t=957746
The questionaire is included in the full aritcle.
1> Best Debater Overall
a) Best Senior Debater…
b) Best Junior Debater…
c) Best Sophomore Debater…
d) Best Fresh(wo)man Debater…
e) Most Improved Debater…
f) Debater With Most Potential…
h) Best Team/Pair…
2> Best Round Overall
a) Best Round You Watched…
b) Best Round You Debated In…
3> Best Program Overall
a) Best Program For Novices…
b) Best New Program…
c) Most Improved Program…
d) Program You’d Most Like To Debate For (Other Than Yours)…
4> Best Argument
a) Best Affirmative Case…
b) Best Counterplan…
c) Best Disadvantage…
d) Best Kritik…
e) Best T/Theory Argument…
5> Best Specific Skills
a) Best 1NC…
b) Best 2AC…
c) Best 2NC…
d) Best 1NR…
d.5) Best 1AR…
e) Best 2NR…
f) Best 2AR…
g) Fastest Debater…
h) Funniest Debater…
6> Other Stuff
a) Favorite Tournament (in-state)…
b) Favorite Tournament (out-of-state)…
c) Favorite Judge/Critic…
d) Weirdest Round You Saw/Debated In…
e) Best Non-Debate Experience at a Debate Tournament…
f) Funniest Thing You Stumbled Upon While Researching…
g) ?
2 Responses to “Thursday Thing to Read: Wisconsin Debate Persona of the Year”
1> Best Debater Overall: Guarav. Damn.
a) Best Senior Debater…Those Brookfield kids and Aaron are pretty impressive.
b) Best Junior Debater…G-bhat
c) Best Sophomore Debater…Osahon
d) Best Fresh(wo)man Debater…I hear the BC machine has some impressive Novi, and Sheboygan North has some kid named Laurel Mills. Remember that name.
e) Most Improved Debater…There’s like a 5.5-way tie here: Nicole Liakopolus, Aaron Champagne, Guarav, the Asad twins, and Nick Brown.
f) Debater With Most Potential…Osahon or Nick
h) Best Team/Pair…Brookfield Central TY/LW
2> Best Round Overall: State Finals….going for theory made it memorable.
a) Best Round You Watched…state finals. that analysis is above
b) Best Round You Debated In…The 5 rounds against Nicole and Max this year were all really close and, not to be blunt, but very highly competitive.
3> Best Program Overall–this year, it was brookfield central, but I would venture to guess that next year, Marquette will dominate.
a) Best Program For Novices…Allison seems to do well with the Brookfield Novices.
b) Best New Program…Is Wausau West new? If they are, then Wausau by default.
c) Most Improved Program…Rufus King. Fo’ sheesh.
d) Program You’d Most Like To Debate For (Other Than Yours)…Marquette….without the whole ‘forced mass’ thing.
4> Best Argument
a) Best Affirmative Case…Padilla v. Hanft. Sorry, but I really liked that case. Aaron’s Nayar affirmative was neat, too.
b) Best Counterplan…Consult.
c) Best Disadvantage…Relations
d) Best Kritik…I am not familiar with the concept of this, how you say, kritik.
e) Best T/Theory Argument…ASPEC
5> Best Specific Skills
a) Best 1NC…Its a 1nc. But Tyler’s always clear, and he gets alot of ink on the flow
b) Best 2AC…Asad: he makes effecient, clear arguments, and they’re usually tough to answer.
c) Best 2NC…Guarav.
d) Best 1NR…Tyler can throw down on the T debate
d.5) Best 1AR…Carly–Gonzo taught her well ;)
e) Best 2NR…Guarav.
f) Best 2AR…
g) Fastest Debater…Annie Chen…work on the clarity, though ;).
h) Funniest Debater…Nick Brown makes me laugh. Alot.
6> Other Stuff
a) Favorite Tournament (in-state)…Appleton East :P
b) Favorite Tournament (out-of-state)…The Glenbrooks
c) Favorite Judge/Critic…Bill Batterman and Kevin Lennon know what’s up. And had he judged more in the state, I’m sure Manav Bhatnagar would be mentioned in this category too.
d) Weirdest Round You Saw/Debated In…The Multitude will meet at Noah’s house. ’nuff said
e) Best Non-Debate Experience at a Debate Tournament…Jeremy Alexander literally tackled me in the hallway of an Illinois hotel. That was quite the experience.
f) Funniest Thing You Stumbled Upon While Researching…Noah and I used to read this Leslie evidence that said deforestation caused an ecological ‘gigadeath’. That, or “brazil key to prevent disasterous consequences”.
g) Thanks Wisconsin Debate, for four pretty sweet years of debate.
By Jonathan on Dec 15, 2005
d) Weirdest Round You Saw/Debated In…The Multitude will meet at Noah’s house. ’nuff said
And despite Nicole’s utopic ideas of the multitudes gathering, we will be having chips and dip.
e) Best Non-Debate Experience at a Debate Tournament…Jeremy Alexander literally tackled me in the hallway of an Illinois hotel. That was quite the experience.
You forgot about the part where he quite literally started punching you in the ass. I bet you had a sweet welt there.
By Noah on Dec 15, 2005