WDCA: Special Award-Winners

Posted on December 10, 2007 – 8:59 am by: Adam Jacobi

Each year, the WDCA bestows special awards to a deserving coach and two deserving graduating seniors.  This year, Neenah’s Osahon Okundaye and Merrill’s Neil Jackson were the scholarship winners, and Bradley Tech’s Ernest Chomicki was Coach of the Year.

Our 2007 WDCA scholarship recipients both have demonstrated a great deal of success at the Wisconsin State Debate Tournament.  They are both renaissance young people, admired for their academic prowess, leadership, service to their schools and communities, and yes, athletic ability in track and field.  They have both been delegates to Badger Boys State and have both competed in national debate tournaments.  They both have competed in Policy Debate since middle school, and competed at the Varsity Level all four years of high school.  They both aspire to careers in law, and will assuredly use their fine analytical and communication skills to work toward justice in our society.

Our first scholarship recipient won a best speaker award in the varsity four-person division at this State Tournament.  A natural leader, this young man has given thoroughly of his time and talents to the 4-H organization, even being elected the first youth member to be elected to his county’s 4-H board of directors executive board as vice president!  Under his tutelage, fundraising efforts have been better organized, bringing harmony to that all too divisive issue of how money is handled.  This debater’s coach writes about how he always has the big picture of his team’s livelihood in mind, and how he was instrumental in her first year on the job.  He is a born teacher and often organizes practices and workshops for the betterment of the school’s squad.   This student’s own words regarding what this activity has offered him are perhaps the most poignant justification for this honor “upon completion of my higher education, I intend on remaining in the state – to contribute to others the same way others have contributed to me.”  Hailing from Merrill High School, congratulations, Neil Jackson!

Our second recipient was part of a State Champion team at this tournament last year.  Also a natural leader, he devotes much of his time to improving his school and others as a student council member, and representative to regional student councils, as well as serving as president of his school’s National Honor Society chapter.  He has been instrumental in exposing his school and community to diversity, proudly representing his Nigerian heritage.  It seems fitting that he should win this award the year our Policy Debaters have discussed how to improve public health assistance in sub-Saharan Africa.  His coach expressed a deep admiration for this young human being, who for his relatively short time on this earth, possesses such great wisdom and compassion for others.  What distinguishes this debater is his affable personality and true regard for his peers above and beyond the arena of competition.  “Courteous to a fault,” his coach writes, he “has served as an amazing example of friendship, dedication and teamwork to the entire Wisconsin debate community.  This student intends to work for a justice-oriented non-governmental organization – hailing from Neenah High School, congratulations, Osahon Okundaye!

This year’s WDCA Coach of the Year candidates bring unrelenting energy to working with their students. They are advocates for debate in their schools and communities, and never hesitate to share their generosity with the overarching debate community for the betterment of this activity. This year’s recipient is a coach at the alma mater this coach once debated at and is also involved in speech activities. This school has gained considerable momentum and success this season. This coach commands an amazing amount of respect from the students he coaches and brings boundless enthusiasm and a quirky sense of humor to our community, always encouraging debaters from his school or others, when it is needed most. Though he may not like the title of “cheerleader” – that’s exactly what he is for this activity. Coach from the Lynde and Harry Bradley Technology and Trade School, Mr. Ernest Chomicki!

WSDT: Four-Person Policy Debate Results

Posted on December 10, 2007 – 8:51 am by: Adam Jacobi

Varsity Policy Debate - Four-Person

Champion: Mukwonago - Alicia Roy & John Skic / Kaitlyn Goodden & Meghan Barrette, 8-2 Record
Runner-Up: Cedarburg - Emily Wilfong & Amanda Hughes / BJ Dwoark & Steve Ward, 7-3 Record
Third Place: Cedarburg - Andy Baumgartner & Nathan Nowicki / Andrew Kobin & Andrew Heidtke, 6-4 Record

Top Affirmative Team: Mukwonago Alicia Roy & John Skic, 4-1
Top Negative Team: Cedarburg BJ Dworak & Steve Ward, 5-0

Speaker Awards
1st Affirmative - Emily Wilfong - Cedarburg - 83 adjusted points
2nd Affirmative - John Skic - Mukwonago - 86 adjusted points
1st Negative - Neil Jackson - Merrill - 85 adjusted points
2nd Negative - Meghan Barrette - Mukwonago - 87 adjusted points

Junior Varsity Four-Person Policy Debate

1). Nicolet #207, 6-0 - Alexis Wilkenson, Jason Schwartz, Rachel Coats, Julia Welytok
2). Rufus King #204, 4-2 (9 Side/19 St Opp) - Chee Thao, Ashley Walton-Stamps, Katarina Shaw, Heather Komas
3). Slinger #212, 4-2 (9 Side/15 St Opp) - Max Merget, Devin Merget, Joel Thielke, Greg Sovinske
4). Merrill #210, 4-2 (8 Side/18 StOpp/2.16 Rank) - Liz Lattoni, Steph Swan, Brittany Polacek, Neal Stahl
5). Muskego #217, 4-2 (8 Side/18 SOpp/2.5 Rank) - Kyle Kaczmarek, Matt Klinka, Andrew Beczkiewicz, Addie Blanchard

Speaker Awards
1A: Lauren Beine, West Bend, 87
2A: Devin Merget, Slinger, 88
1N: Katarina Shaw, Rufus King, 81
2N: Julia Welytok, Nicolet, 86

Novice Four-Person Policy Debate

1). Milwaukee Arts #302, 6-0 (14 StOpp) - Jana Wisniewski, Kirsten Wisniewski, Cesar Carbajal, Alyssa Ray-Alden
2). Rhinelander #317, 6-0 (11 StOpp) - Ryan Gittins, Joel McReynolds, Eric Kirbus, David Walters
3). Marquette #301, 5-1 - Michael Hoffman, Jack McKay, Jacob Biefka, Alex Kendall
4). Wausau West #312, 4-2 (10 Side) - Lucas Hohn, Neha Phuja, Heather Landrum, Kelsey McEachen
5). Marquette #305, 4-2 (9 Side) - Alex Beck, Cameron Gratt, Joe Handlos, Sam Schenrell

Speaker Awards
1A: Jana Wisniewski, Milwaukee Arts, 87
2A: Kirsten Wisniewski, Milwaukee Arts, 86
1N: Cesar Carbajal, Milwaukee Arts, 84
2N: Alyssa Ray-Alden, Milwaukee Arts, 86

Middle Level Four-Person Policy Debate

1). Golda Meir #407, 6-0 - Blaque Robinson, Paul Meyer, Dennis Lewis, Brittany Nienhardt
2). Golda Meir #403, 5-1 - Katherine Taylor, Chloe Loomis, Matthew Lewis, Maddie Budney
3). Fritsche #401, 4-2 - Joe Fitzgerald, Alex Sanchez, Melissa Justus, Sonia Escamilla
4). Fritsche #405, 3-3 - Jacob Sanchez, Victor Trussel, James Elias, Jordan Wright
5). Neenah #404, 2-4 - Trent Rogers, Jackee Rooney, Mark Caringello, Elijah Kees
Speaker Awards
1A: Blaque Robinson, Golda Meir, 86
2A: Alex Sanchez, Fritsche, 85
1N: Matthew Lewis, Golda Meir, 86
2N: Brittany Nienhardt, Golda Meir, 84

Monday Meditation: WI Debate Persona of the Year

Posted on December 10, 2007 – 8:21 am by: Nick Bubb

For the last five years a Wisconsin State tournament reflection post shows up either on cross-x.com or right here on WFD. That reflection post, entitled “Wisconsin Debate Persona of the Year” asks the community a series of questions to nominate who they felt has done the best this year. WFD encourages everyone to participate in the reflection of the year that was in Wisconsin Debate.

The questionnaire is included in the full article.

1> Best Debater Overall
a) Best Senior Debater…
b) Best Junior Debater…
c) Best Sophomore Debater…
d) Best Fresh(wo)man Debater…
e) Most Improved Debater…
f) Debater With Most Potential…
h) Best Team/Pair…

2> Best Round Overall
a) Best Round You Watched…
b) Best Round You Debated In…

3> Best Program Overall
a) Best Program For Novices…
b) Best New Program…
c) Most Improved Program…
d) Program You’d Most Like To Debate For (Other Than Yours)…

4> Best Argument
a) Best Affirmative Case…
b) Best Counterplan…
c) Best Disadvantage…
d) Best Kritik…
e) Best T/Theory Argument…

5> Best Specific Skills
a) Best 1NC…
b) Best 2AC…
c) Best 2NC…
d) Best 1NR…
d.5) Best 1AR…
e) Best 2NR…
f) Best 2AR…
g) Fastest Debater…
h) Funniest Debater…

6> Other Stuff
a) Favorite Tournament (in-state)…
b) Favorite Tournament (out-of-state)…
c) Favorite Judge/Critic…
d) Weirdest Round You Saw/Debated In…
e) Best Non-Debate Experience at a Debate Tournament…
f) Funniest Thing You Stumbled Upon While Researching…
g) ?

WDCA: Special Award-Winners

Posted on December 10, 2007 – 6:59 am by: Adam Jacobi

Each year, the WDCA bestows special awards to a deserving coach and two deserving graduating seniors.  This year, Neenah’s Osahon Okundaye and Merrill’s Neil Jackson were the scholarship winners, and Bradley Tech’s Ernest Chomicki was Coach of the Year.

Read the rest of this entry »

WSDT: Four-Person Policy Debate Results

Posted on December 10, 2007 – 6:51 am by: Adam Jacobi

Varsity Policy Debate - Four-Person

Champion: Mukwonago - Alicia Roy & John Skic / Kaitlyn Goodden & Meghan Barrette, 8-2 Record
Runner-Up: Cedarburg - Emily Wilfong & Amanda Hughes / BJ Dwoark & Steve Ward, 7-3 Record
Third Place: Cedarburg - Andy Baumgartner & Nathan Nowicki / Andrew Kobin & Andrew Heidtke, 6-4 Record

Read the rest of this entry »

Monday Meditation: WI Debate Persona of the Year

Posted on December 10, 2007 – 6:21 am by: Nick Bubb

For the last five years a Wisconsin State tournament reflection post shows up either on cross-x.com or right here on WFD. That reflection post, entitled “Wisconsin Debate Persona of the Year” asks the community a series of questions to nominate who they felt has done the best this year. WFD encourages everyone to participate in the reflection of the year that was in Wisconsin Debate.

The questionnaire is included in the full article.

1> Best Debater Overall
a) Best Senior Debater…
b) Best Junior Debater…
c) Best Sophomore Debater…
d) Best Fresh(wo)man Debater…
e) Most Improved Debater…
f) Debater With Most Potential…
h) Best Team/Pair…

2> Best Round Overall
a) Best Round You Watched…
b) Best Round You Debated In…

3> Best Program Overall
a) Best Program For Novices…
b) Best New Program…
c) Most Improved Program…
d) Program You’d Most Like To Debate For (Other Than Yours)…

4> Best Argument
a) Best Affirmative Case…
b) Best Counterplan…
c) Best Disadvantage…
d) Best Kritik…
e) Best T/Theory Argument…

5> Best Specific Skills
a) Best 1NC…
b) Best 2AC…
c) Best 2NC…
d) Best 1NR…
d.5) Best 1AR…
e) Best 2NR…
f) Best 2AR…
g) Fastest Debater…
h) Funniest Debater…

6> Other Stuff
a) Favorite Tournament (in-state)…
b) Favorite Tournament (out-of-state)…
c) Favorite Judge/Critic…
d) Weirdest Round You Saw/Debated In…
e) Best Non-Debate Experience at a Debate Tournament…
f) Funniest Thing You Stumbled Upon While Researching…
g) ?

WDCA: Special Award-Winners

Posted on December 10, 2007 – 4:59 am by: Adam Jacobi

Each year, the WDCA bestows special awards to a deserving coach and two deserving graduating seniors.  This year, Neenah’s Osahon Okundaye and Merrill’s Neil Jackson were the scholarship winners, and Bradley Tech’s Ernest Chomicki was Coach of the Year.

Our 2007 WDCA scholarship recipients both have demonstrated a great deal of success at the Wisconsin State Debate Tournament.  They are both renaissance young people, admired for their academic prowess, leadership, service to their schools and communities, and yes, athletic ability in track and field.  They have both been delegates to Badger Boys State and have both competed in national debate tournaments.  They both have competed in Policy Debate since middle school, and competed at the Varsity Level all four years of high school.  They both aspire to careers in law, and will assuredly use their fine analytical and communication skills to work toward justice in our society.

Our first scholarship recipient won a best speaker award in the varsity four-person division at this State Tournament.  A natural leader, this young man has given thoroughly of his time and talents to the 4-H organization, even being elected the first youth member to be elected to his county’s 4-H board of directors executive board as vice president!  Under his tutelage, fundraising efforts have been better organized, bringing harmony to that all too divisive issue of how money is handled.  This debater’s coach writes about how he always has the big picture of his team’s livelihood in mind, and how he was instrumental in her first year on the job.  He is a born teacher and often organizes practices and workshops for the betterment of the school’s squad.   This student’s own words regarding what this activity has offered him are perhaps the most poignant justification for this honor “upon completion of my higher education, I intend on remaining in the state – to contribute to others the same way others have contributed to me.”  Hailing from Merrill High School, congratulations, Neil Jackson!

Our second recipient was part of a State Champion team at this tournament last year.  Also a natural leader, he devotes much of his time to improving his school and others as a student council member, and representative to regional student councils, as well as serving as president of his school’s National Honor Society chapter.  He has been instrumental in exposing his school and community to diversity, proudly representing his Nigerian heritage.  It seems fitting that he should win this award the year our Policy Debaters have discussed how to improve public health assistance in sub-Saharan Africa.  His coach expressed a deep admiration for this young human being, who for his relatively short time on this earth, possesses such great wisdom and compassion for others.  What distinguishes this debater is his affable personality and true regard for his peers above and beyond the arena of competition.  “Courteous to a fault,” his coach writes, he “has served as an amazing example of friendship, dedication and teamwork to the entire Wisconsin debate community.  This student intends to work for a justice-oriented non-governmental organization – hailing from Neenah High School, congratulations, Osahon Okundaye!

This year’s WDCA Coach of the Year candidates bring unrelenting energy to working with their students. They are advocates for debate in their schools and communities, and never hesitate to share their generosity with the overarching debate community for the betterment of this activity. This year’s recipient is a coach at the alma mater this coach once debated at and is also involved in speech activities. This school has gained considerable momentum and success this season. This coach commands an amazing amount of respect from the students he coaches and brings boundless enthusiasm and a quirky sense of humor to our community, always encouraging debaters from his school or others, when it is needed most. Though he may not like the title of “cheerleader” – that’s exactly what he is for this activity. Coach from the Lynde and Harry Bradley Technology and Trade School, Mr. Ernest Chomicki!

WSDT: Four-Person Policy Debate Results

Posted on December 10, 2007 – 4:51 am by: Adam Jacobi

Varsity Policy Debate - Four-Person

Champion: Mukwonago - Alicia Roy & John Skic / Kaitlyn Goodden & Meghan Barrette, 8-2 Record
Runner-Up: Cedarburg - Emily Wilfong & Amanda Hughes / BJ Dwoark & Steve Ward, 7-3 Record
Third Place: Cedarburg - Andy Baumgartner & Nathan Nowicki / Andrew Kobin & Andrew Heidtke, 6-4 Record

Top Affirmative Team: Mukwonago Alicia Roy & John Skic, 4-1
Top Negative Team: Cedarburg BJ Dworak & Steve Ward, 5-0

Speaker Awards
1st Affirmative - Emily Wilfong - Cedarburg - 83 adjusted points
2nd Affirmative - John Skic - Mukwonago - 86 adjusted points
1st Negative - Neil Jackson - Merrill - 85 adjusted points
2nd Negative - Meghan Barrette - Mukwonago - 87 adjusted points

Junior Varsity Four-Person Policy Debate

1). Nicolet #207, 6-0 - Alexis Wilkenson, Jason Schwartz, Rachel Coats, Julia Welytok
2). Rufus King #204, 4-2 (9 Side/19 St Opp) - Chee Thao, Ashley Walton-Stamps, Katarina Shaw, Heather Komas
3). Slinger #212, 4-2 (9 Side/15 St Opp) - Max Merget, Devin Merget, Joel Thielke, Greg Sovinske
4). Merrill #210, 4-2 (8 Side/18 StOpp/2.16 Rank) - Liz Lattoni, Steph Swan, Brittany Polacek, Neal Stahl
5). Muskego #217, 4-2 (8 Side/18 SOpp/2.5 Rank) - Kyle Kaczmarek, Matt Klinka, Andrew Beczkiewicz, Addie Blanchard

Speaker Awards
1A: Lauren Beine, West Bend, 87
2A: Devin Merget, Slinger, 88
1N: Katarina Shaw, Rufus King, 81
2N: Julia Welytok, Nicolet, 86

Novice Four-Person Policy Debate

1). Milwaukee Arts #302, 6-0 (14 StOpp) - Jana Wisniewski, Kirsten Wisniewski, Cesar Carbajal, Alyssa Ray-Alden
2). Rhinelander #317, 6-0 (11 StOpp) - Ryan Gittins, Joel McReynolds, Eric Kirbus, David Walters
3). Marquette #301, 5-1 - Michael Hoffman, Jack McKay, Jacob Biefka, Alex Kendall
4). Wausau West #312, 4-2 (10 Side) - Lucas Hohn, Neha Phuja, Heather Landrum, Kelsey McEachen
5). Marquette #305, 4-2 (9 Side) - Alex Beck, Cameron Gratt, Joe Handlos, Sam Schenrell

Speaker Awards
1A: Jana Wisniewski, Milwaukee Arts, 87
2A: Kirsten Wisniewski, Milwaukee Arts, 86
1N: Cesar Carbajal, Milwaukee Arts, 84
2N: Alyssa Ray-Alden, Milwaukee Arts, 86

Middle Level Four-Person Policy Debate

1). Golda Meir #407, 6-0 - Blaque Robinson, Paul Meyer, Dennis Lewis, Brittany Nienhardt
2). Golda Meir #403, 5-1 - Katherine Taylor, Chloe Loomis, Matthew Lewis, Maddie Budney
3). Fritsche #401, 4-2 - Joe Fitzgerald, Alex Sanchez, Melissa Justus, Sonia Escamilla
4). Fritsche #405, 3-3 - Jacob Sanchez, Victor Trussel, James Elias, Jordan Wright
5). Neenah #404, 2-4 - Trent Rogers, Jackee Rooney, Mark Caringello, Elijah Kees
Speaker Awards
1A: Blaque Robinson, Golda Meir, 86
2A: Alex Sanchez, Fritsche, 85
1N: Matthew Lewis, Golda Meir, 86
2N: Brittany Nienhardt, Golda Meir, 84

Marquette BF Wins Varsity Switch Side

Posted on December 8, 2007 – 10:51 pm by: Nick Bubb

After six rounds of debate, six teams possessed a winning record. The tournament cleared to a partial quarterfinal. In the final round, the affirmative team of Garrett Fields and Joe Balistreri debated the Sheboygan North team of Tim Knoedler and Laurel Mills. Marquette won the round on a decision 4-1. Marquette is coached by Bill Batterman and Sheboygan North is coached by Jon Voss.

Partial Quarters
1) Sheboygan North KM advances without debating
2) SPASH LM advandes without debating
3) Marquette BF over Marquette BG (Ben Benson and Dave Gephart)
4) Marquette CK (neg) d. Appleton East PV (Caitlin Peterson and Amanda Verbick) 3-0 ()

Semifinals
Sheboygan North (aff) KM d. Marquette CK (Mark Kettler and Noah Charles) 2-1 (Olson*, Onkles, Hager)
Marquette BF d. SPASH LM (Ian Miller and Emily Langhorst) 2-1 (Quenette*, Shah, Degneffe)

Finals
Marquette BF (aff) d. Sheboygan North KM (Tim Knoedler and Laurel Mills) 4-1 (Hager*, Degeneffe, Wang, Olson, Henning)

Champion
Marquette BF (Garett Fields and Joe Balistreri)

Appleton East wins Public Forum

Posted on December 8, 2007 – 10:27 pm by: Nick Bubb

In the largest varsity division at the state tournament, Public Forum cleared to partial octafinals after six rounds. In the final round, the Appleton East team of Kyle Krueger and Ruth Markwardt debated the con side of the resolution against the pro team of Ben Rice and Alicia Taggatz from Waupaca. On a 4-1 decision, the Appleton East team prevailed. Full results follow below. Appleton East is coached by Mike Traas and Waupaca is coached by Neil Young.


Partial Octafinals
1) Marquette SS advances without debating
2) Waupaca RT advances without debating
3) Waupaca HM advances without debating
4) Appleton East KM (Con) d. Hortonville LT (Johnathon Lambert and Chris Tassoul) 2-1 (Tellock, Wilson, Pfeiffer*)
5) Cedarburg GL (Con) d. James Madison Memorial GY (Suvai Gunasekaran) 3-0 (Knuth, Powell, Fisher)
6) James Madison Memorial (Con) KS d. James Madison Memorial SW (Abilash Seshardi and Rachel Wang) 2-1 (Erbes*, Bain, Longhram)
7) Appleton East (Con) LT d. Cedarburg AA (Emily Anderson and Sammy Anderson) 2-1 (Dornberger, Pestlin*, Farvour)
9) Cedarburg KS (Con) d. Appleton West BD (David Bronson and Andy Diedrich) 2-1 (Bleicher, Graf, Pickering*)

Quarterfinals
1) Marquette SS (Con) d. Cedarburg KS (Nick Kuznacic and Alaina Sullivan) 2-1 (Wojcik, Soik, Pfeiffer*)
2) Waupaca RT (Pro) d. Appleton East LT (Mark Lindsay and Leah Tabbert) 2-1 (Tellock, Longhram*, Erbes)
6) James Madison Memorial KS (Con) d. Waupaca HM (Kristen Hendrickson and Ryan Manteufel) 2-1 (Bleicher, Carew*, Wilson)
4) Appleton East KM (Con) d. Cedarburg GL (Lauren Gould and Kaybe Longhram) 2-1 (Bain*, Dornberger, Sephus-Chapman)

Semifinals
4) Appleton East KM (Pro) d. Marquette SS (Robert Schlaeger and Jacob Sirus) 2-1 (Knuth, Pestlin*, Hagmann)
2) Waupaca RT (Pro) d. James Madison Memorial KS (Lingran Kong and Valerie Shen) 3-0 (Wojcik, Sephus-Chapman, Powell)

Finals
4) Appleton East KM (Con) d. Waupaca RT (Ben Rice and Alicia Taggatz) 4-1 (Soik*, Graf, Erbes, Sephus-Chapman, Sullivan)

Champion
Appleton East KM (Kyle Krueger and Ruth Markwardt)