Thursday Thing to Read: Double Entry at WFCA State

Posted on March 4, 2010 – 9:02 am by: Nick Bubb

Having been proposed and discussed at several WFCA meetings, Wisconsin Forensics Daily would like to turn its attention to the Double Entry Proposal for the WFCA State Tournament. The current WFCA State Tournament only allows a student to enter into a single event. Schools are capped with a 25-person team and cannot enter more than four students in a single category. The proposal would keep both the 25-person and 4 entries per category caps, but would allow students to enter into more than one event.

A summary of the current proposal is below the break. Additional proposals are forth coming, and separate posts will be made as soon as they are available. Read the rest of this entry »

Monday Meditation: Stop Reading Codes at Awards

Posted on February 22, 2010 – 6:53 am by: Adam Jacobi

Trophy CupA Call to Action for Tournament Directors

When I first started coaching  13 years ago, students were never known by more than their codes at forensics tournaments.  The awards announcer would proclaim, “and in first place, Solo Acting Serious,  from Anyville school, 42R3!”  In the meanwhile, awards ceremonies have become a classier affair, with standing ovations for the first place champion, and standards for tact enumerated in the WFCA Code of Conduct.

In the early part of the new millennium, I experimented at some tournaments with running PowerPoint presentations during awards, sliding names and schools behind the contestants.  I was actually inspired by the spectacle that is the NFL National Tournament Awards program, and wanted to bring some of that celebration of students to our local competitions.  In order to make this work, we needed to collect students’ names during the finals (power) rounds.  The second set of typing in PowerPoint added a few extra minutes of waiting before awards, and whomever would operate the PowerPoint slides might advance a name a few seconds too early, ruining the suspense of announcement.  So, the practice was dropped in favor of more efficient, shorter awards ceremonies — about the same time the “One-Clap” method of recognizing finalists took wing.

By then, however, the practice of collecting names and announcing them during the awards ceremonies became a norm, and a form was even added to the WFCA Handbook, tournament forms section to facilitate collection of this information.  As Mike Traas began more freely distributing his amazing Microsoft Access file for tabulating tournaments, that feature was built-in to allow reading of names and inclusion of them in the results packets — and subsequent posting online here at Wisconsin Forensics Daily.  When I piloted TabRoom.com at the Alverno tournament this year, I was pleased to see that it preserved ink/toner for the reading script generated, only showing students’ names — with phonetic key based on pronunciation guides coaches typed during online registration — and schools.  The only exception was Group Interp. and Play Acting script pages printed by title (so I’ll have to ask the developer of that software if he can incorporate an option for names instead).

So, with all this technology and desire for fast and efficient awards assemblies, why do we perpetuate the practice of gratuitously reading codes during awards ceremonies?  The tournament is over; let’s celebrate the students and the schools they hail from, not the temporary system used to mask their identities up to that point!

Respectfully,
Adam Jacobi
Former Coach, Rufus King HS & Director, Alverno College Tournament

Thursday Thing to Read: Help the NFL Give Away Pepsi’s Money

Posted on February 4, 2010 – 10:15 am by: Nick Bubb

Yes. It’s back. Sort of.

The National Forensic League has released the following message:

NFL is a finalist for Pepsi’s Refresh Everything grant, which helps groups from across the country improve their local communities. NFL’s proposal will create weekend-long communication leadership summits in six major cities for students and teachers in Title I schools. Most of the grant money will be given directly to students, teachers, and coaches in the six major cities we serve. That’s over $210,000 directly into the hands of deserving students and educators.

We need your help to reach our goal! Grant recipients will be decided by community votes. Voting is open now! You may vote every day from today through the end of February. Visit NFL Online to read our entire proposal and vote to make speech and debate education available to new populations.

Also, here’s my random plug for Pepsi: Mountain Dew Throwback has been re-released. You’ve been notified.

Proposing: Wisconsin Debate Cup

Posted on October 2, 2009 – 11:15 am by: Nick Bubb

In an effort to increase participation and excitement in local Minnesota debate tournaments, the Minnesota Debate Teachers Association (the functional equivalent of the Wisconsin Debate Coaches Association) has created the MDTA Cup. Similar to the FedEx and Sprint Cups (Golf’s and NASCAR’s season trophy), points are awarded based on how schools/individuals/drivers/golfers fare during the regular season and the school/individual/driver/golfer with the most points wins the cup. A full explanation about what Minnesota is doing can be found on the MDTA website (link).

I propose that Wisconsin implement something similar to the school with the most points at the end of the season. This would provide squads an additional incentive to attend Wisconsin tournaments and would be an interesting alternative to our long-removed sweepstakes and coaches awards. The interesting thing is that this would be a *season long* award, so its some what different than a school’s performance at the state tournament. My personal thought is that Minnesota is a bit over doing it by creating an overall school award, and then separate awards for each kind of debate in Minnesota. To be interesting and prestigious – there should be one Wisconsin Debate Cup (which would need a much cooler name) and it should be accessible to all forms of debate.

The most agreeable point structure for Wisconsin is probably: one point for each entry, one point for each pair/team/student with a winning record at a tournament, one point for being the tournament’s champion/first place team (no elimination rounds used). This way, the maximum number of points you could earn with one pair at a tournament is three. Although a possible revision is: 1pt/entry, 1pt/winning record, 2pts/champion, 1pt/elimination round won – five points maximum at a tournament. The point structure plus the cap would reward switch teams that endure 9 rounds to reach a championship a one point bump over V4 teams. You can drop the championship distinction down to two, and this would create a two point gap between VSS and V4 – but I think it’s probably better to have a one point gap, if any at all.

We could propose more sophisticated point structures, but my guess is that they would be controversial to implement. For example, we could award more points to tournaments with larger competition fields (or create a multiplier for larger competition fields). But I imagine that people who don’t want to attend these tournaments would be annoyed that they were being eliminated from the competition. In some ways, that objection makes little sense – if the point of the award is to increase participation/excitement about local tournaments, then they shouldn’t complain about their choice to avoid tournaments.  Additionally, I think that a need for a multiplier might also be taken care of in the difficulty of the tournament. For example, if a tournament is really hard: the ability for teams to achieve a winning record will be reduced. Meaning the points for the tournament are lower for everyone – so any points that a school is able to earn a difficult tournament would produce more of a separation between them and rest of the field. We could also do something similar to what golf does with the “Tour Championship.” We could have the standings re-set to a particular amount, so that the top seed remains, but school in theory has a chance to win the cup.

What I think I will do is keep statistics based on this year. If it ends up going well, then I think I may recommend a proposal for implementation at the Spring Meeting. Thoughts?

Thursday Thing to Read: How to be a Good Second Negative

Posted on December 18, 2008 – 4:12 pm by: Nick Bubb

Paul Hager was recently asked how to be a good Second Negative. He started typing and didn’t stop. This is what came out… Read on as Paul tells all secrets about how to win on the negative with a core counterplan or Kritik as your route to victory.

The Duties of  Good Second Negative by Paul Hager.

Read the rest of this entry »

Tuesday Thing to Do: VOTE

Posted on November 4, 2008 – 12:21 pm by: Nick Bubb

Wisconsin Forensics Daily encourages you to vote. There are many issues facing our country and our nation’s leadership needs to respond to those issues. In order to make our leaders listen, you need to vote.

Voting is very easy in Wisconsin. All you need is a photo ID and a proof of address (and to be over 18). You can register to vote at the polls, so you don’t need to be registered already. Even if you don’t have a proof of address, you can still vote if you have a registered voter in your district vouch for you. So there are many issues at stake and voting is really easy. Our question to you is: why are you NOT voting?

Folks also can use this thread to explain who they voted for and why.

Tags:

Monday Meditation: WFCA State Thank You

Posted on April 27, 2008 – 9:46 pm by: Nick Bubb

WFCA President Bonni Knight asked Wisconsin Forensics Daily to post this thank you letter:

Dear Fellow Coaches and Friends,

I want to take a moment to thank you all for your hard work throughout the season, and especially last weekend, to help make the 2008 WFCA State Tournament a success. Congratulations to everyone. Whether or not your students came home with trophies cannot be a true measure of what was won that day. Last Saturday was a tribute to hard work and dedication on the part of students and coaches alike. In the end, talent (and a little luck, sometimes) brought the winners to the stage, but every kid who showed up was changed by the performances they saw and the ballots they received.

As I stated in the listening sessions throughout the day, I am inspired by the dedication of the people who make the tournament possible. The list is long, but permit me to mention a few of them:

Chris Zoch – Tournament Director. This man did a superhuman job of organizing and scheduling this event, always displaying gentility and grace, even in the most stressful of moments. Without his attention to detail, the tournament could have been a disaster.

Deano Pape – Site Director. After the tournament was over, and everyone had left, I observed Deano carefully straightening the rows of chairs in the gym for an event the following morning. I cannot imagine how much work this must have been for him, but I do know this… his ability to inspire the team of cheerful college team members to get up and be there at 7 am on a Saturday is truly impressive.

Jodi Becker – Site Coordinator. It was Jodi who arranged all the coordination of details. Throughout the day, I was impressed by her ability to juggle countless details about rooms, concessions, etc, all the while smiling calmly.

Mike Traas – Tab Room Director. Wow. Data flowed through the computers, set up and managed by Mike. His staff performed effectively and cheerfully, and everything went very smoothly. This room was a sight to behold, with teams of focused professionals hunched over their computers muttering numbers to each other, allowing the tournament to conclude almost exactly on schedule.

Paul Seymour – Tournament Assistant. I met Paul at a meeting room at the Country Inn on Friday night, where he was leading a staff of volunteers in stuffing packets and organizing judges. Another detail person, his work really moved the tournament along.

Father Gary Wegner – Tournament Practices and Procedures Chair. The large number of protests and complaints brought to this committee was, I believe, unprecedented. But Gary and his team heard both sides of every story, and always made every effort to give people the opportunity to speak in defense of the protest. I was most impressed with Gary’s common sense approach to things, as well as his gentleness during conflicts. Also, hats off to Joe Meinecke for his quick use of Google to try and help people prove the validity of their cuttings.

Adam Jacobi – Congress Director: Adam’s dedication to the activity of Student Congress is legendary, as is his passion and talent. The day went smoothly, and everything was handled professionally. Adam’s decision to move the congress to earlier in the day has truly improved the event, as it allows kids to “give it their all” and still have something left for the next day.

Steve Sexton – Past President. Steve was responsible for organizing the scholarships and awards. Thanks for providing inspirational insight into all of the great winners.

I mention all of those people and their actions because I think sometimes we take for granted the generous dedication of these volunteers. It is easy to pay your dues and registration fees, and just show up without ever wondering how it all takes place. The fact that an event of this magnitude can be run completely by a group of dedicated volunteers in truly unbelievable. But many of us are nearing retirement age, and it is time for more members to step up and volunteer. Host an invitational tournament. Host a workshop. Volunteer for a committee. Run for office. Have a say in the future of this group. And think about attending the Spring Meeting in Fond du Lac on May 2 – 3. Get to know us. Let us help you. You may contact me with any questions.

Finally, as many of you may already know, my assistant coach, Steve Sparks, passed away in August at the age of 26 from a pulmonary embolism, devastating me and my students. I also lost my brother-in-law, my next-door neighbor, and several friends this year. It ended up being one of the most difficult years of my life. But it also taught me something: You can never count on someone or something to be there tomorrow. You have to live life to its fullest every second. To me that meant many things: coaching my students with every ounce of energy that I possessed, spending precious time with my beloved family traveling to Belize for Christmas, visiting a friend in Vermont, or in the hospital, shopping occasionally (or more than occasionally), and trying to lead a complex organization that, because it is composed of people, can be full of conflict. I urge all of you to move forward and work together for the good of your students, and for all Wisconsin forensicators. Life is too short to hold on to disagreements and conflict. And our students deserve our best work.

It has been a genuine honor to be president of such a dynamic, vital organization.

Sincerely,

Bonni Knight

Thursday Thing to Read: WDCA 2008 Schedule

Posted on April 10, 2008 – 8:16 am by: Nick Bubb

With several tournaments having the distinct possibility of moving and the schedule conflicts that have existed over the last season, Wisconsin Forensics Daily is interested in taking the lead in a discussion about the 2008 Debate Season Schedule in hopes of resolving any potential conflicts before they arise. In case some of you haven’t heard, the Appleton East Challenge potentially will not exist next season. We are also returning to a year where there are more weekends in September than we have had in the past. Hopefully with this work we can develop a 2008 schedule that works with Milwaukee Debate League, develops three large tournament before the state tournament, and avoids regionally conflicted tournaments. (And since that I’ve been reviewing the standing rules, I know that this was supposed to be resolved by today).

What follows below is a list of next year’s dates. I’ve listed the possibilities of tournaments on a particular date as well. I’ve tried to note what is going on with the National Circuit where appropriate:

Sept 12-13: Wake Forest, WDCA Fall Meeting
Sept 19-20: Marquette
Sept 26-27: Nicolet?, Valley?
Oct 3-4: Rufus King, Merrill?, New Trier
Oct 10-11: Hortonville, West Bend
Oct 17-18: LaCrosse, South Milwaukee?
Oct 24-25: Open,
Oct 31-Nov 1: Teachers Convention, Mukwonago?, Caucus/EGR?
Nov 7-8: (Sheboygan North if can’t move), Michigan
Nov 14-15: Janesville/Madison Memorial
Nov 21-22: Sheboygan South, Glenbrooks
Dec 5-6: Sheboygan North/Appleton East, Greendale/Hale
Dec 12-13: WDCA-WHSFA State, location TBA

If the first weekend of December is open (as in Appleton East is not hosting), then Sheboygan North would like to take that weekend and continue the tradition of running the challenge.

Tags:

Wisconsin Forensics Daily 2.0

Posted on April 4, 2008 – 9:58 am by: Nick Bubb

I sent this message out to just about everyone in my contact book, but I’m certain I forgot some people. In case I did, here’s the full message:

Friends in Forensics and Debate,

I know this list is far from a complete listing of those that compete in forensics and debate in Wisconsin, so please help me in forwarding this message to those who I have left out. Three years ago I had an idea to develop an independent website to help bring the Wisconsin forensics and debate community together. Later that fall we launched our first website and began the work of collaborating to improve debate and forensics in Wisconsin.

Today we have completed a massive overhaul of the design and technological systems of that website. On this occasion, I want to renew the call of Wisconsin Forensics Daily’s mission. We seek to create a community that can collaborate to improve debate and forensics in Wisconsin, without being limited by ideological, geographic, or financial barriers. Please join us in our constant discussions and come celebrate the success of our students.

Thank you,

Nick Bubb
Wisconsin Forensics Daily
Editor-in-Chief

Monday Meditation: The Importance of Coaches

Posted on March 3, 2008 – 6:32 am by: Nick Bubb

Late last year, Steve Sparks – an assistant forensics coach to Eau Claire North High School, died suddenly of a a pulmonary embolism. At the first Steve Sparks Memorial Tournament at Eau Claire North earlier this year, head coach Bonni Knight delivered a moving speech on the impact that coaches and forensics have on student’s lives. I have asked Bonni to share the text of her speech with Wisconsin Forensics Daily and it follows below the break.

Read the rest of this entry »